Categorieën
Ethiek Technologie Theologie

Recensie Christian Ethics for a Digital Society – Kate Ott

Big Tech

Digitale technologie speelt een steeds grotere rol in ons dagelijks leven en de macht van de grote technologieplatformen, vaak Big Tech genoemd, ligt steeds meer onder een vergrootglas. Het is dan ook niet verwonderlijk dat er steeds vaker theologische boeken verschijnen waarin een kritische en ethische reflectie hierop wordt gegeven. Door haar verfrissende aanpak is het boek van Kate Ott is een welkome aanvulling hierop. Zij verbindt op kundige wijze actuele thema’s uit de wereld van digitale technologie aan theologische en ethische reflectie. De auteur, die als docent christelijke ethiek verbonden is aan de theologische faculteit van de Drew universiteit in de Verenigde Staten, gaat in haar boek op zoek naar een manier hoe je als christen op een ethische en verantwoorde manier digitale technologie kan gebruiken om te komen tot een meer diverse en inclusievere wereld. Zij beschrijft en duidt de technologische verschijnselen vanuit het buiten-perspectief van iemand die geen achtergrond in deze materie heeft.

Digitale geletterdheid

Tijdens deze ontdekkingsreis vertrekt ze vanuit haar eigen achtergrond, christelijke feministische ethiek, en geeft een treffend beeld van hoe digitale technologie werkt en op welke manier dit ons leven reeds vormt, hetgeen vanuit technologisch perspectief zeer accuraat wordt weergegeven. Wat dit boek interessant maakt voor de theoloog, predikant en religiewetenschapper, is dat Ott de technologische thematiek op inventieve wijze weet te voorzien van een hermeneutisch vocabulaire, waardoor je in de theologische praktijk beter in staat bent om technologische vraagstukken te interpreteren. Als rode draad door haar boek heen, pleit Ott voor meer digitale geletterdheid (digital literacy) bij christenen. Om tot een goede ethische reflectie en actie te komen, is het essentieel om een basale kennis te hebben hoe digitale technologie werkt en het ons leven vormgeeft.

Algoritmes

Het beste voorbeeld hiervan staat direct in het eerste hoofdstuk van het boek, Programming for Difference, waarin Ott je op indringende manier laat zien hoe algoritmes onze wereld vormgeven en onze keuzes beïnvloeden. Doordat algoritmes zorgdragen voor persoonlijke adviezen op maat lijkt het alsof deze zorgen voor meer diversiteit, echter Ott toont aan dat algoritmes mensen reduceren tot kwantificeerbare eenheden waardoor een “dominantie van gelijkheid” (34) optreedt. Het paradoxale effect van algoritmes is dat zij dus gelijkheid benadrukt en uitvergroot en daardoor diversiteit vermindert. Aan de hand van het verhaal uit de Bijbel over de toren van Babel (Gen. 11:1-9) maakt de schrijfster duidelijk dat diversiteit juist een feature van de schepping van God die wij als christenen zouden moeten nastreven. God veroordeelt het gebruik van één taal omdat dit alle verschillen uit zou wissen en gebruikt de spraakverwarring om meer diversiteit terug te brengen in de schepping. De algoritmes van Big Tech werken volgens Ott als de bouwers van de toren van Babel en benadrukken eenheid in plaats van diversiteit. Dit leidt juist tot uitvergroting en versterking van vooroordelen die reeds in onze maatschappij aanwezig zijn. Ott gebruikt de theologische notie van mede-schepper (co-creator) om de lezer op haar morele verantwoordelijkheid te wijzen en haar op een bewuste en proportionele manier om te laten gaan met algoritmes, om zo op een actieve manier een meer diverse wereld te creëren.

Tech Giants on the other hand consider digital technology and electronic communication a way of regaining what was lost at Babel. They suggest both through translation and the ubiquity of common media that again one language is being created. 1

Identiteit

Ook in de hierop volgende hoofdstukken, die gaan over (digitale) identiteit en relaties, het eeuwigdurende geheugen van digitale platformen en de gevolgen die technologie heeft voor het milieu, weet Ott boeiend de technologische pijnpunten bloot te leggen en hier een theologische en ethische reflectie op te geven. In het laatste hoofdstuk, Ethical Hacking and Hacking Ethics, claimt Ott dat we als christen de mindset moeten hebben van een computer hacker. Het is onze taak om te wijzen op het onrecht en ongelijkheid dat digitale technologie kan veroorzaken en hiernaar te handelen om zo te komen tot een betere, dus meer diverse en inclusievere, wereld.

Waarom dit boek lezen?

Het boek is een goede manier om op een theologische manier over de morele uitdagingen die digitale technologie met zich meebrengt te doordenken. Wel zie je duidelijk in de hermeneutische richting die de auteur kiest, dat zij haar oorsprong heeft in feministische en bevrijdingstheologie. Doordat zij hier vanaf het begin zeer open en duidelijk over is, maakt het dat dit boek extra aanzet om je eigen positie te bepalen en kritisch na te denken. Mijn kritiek op het boek dat het een te eenzijdig beeld geeft over de rol die digitale technologie speelt in ons leven. De focus van de auteur is vooral gericht op de negatieve gevolgen die digitale technologie met zich meebrengt. Om echter tot een genuanceerd ethisch oordeel over digitale technologie te komen, is het aan te bevelen om aanvullende literatuur waarin de voordelen van digitale technologie zijn uitgewerkt te raadplegen.

Bibliografie

Ott, Kate M. Christian Ethics for a Digital Society. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield, 2019.

Categorieën
Ethiek Technologie Theologie

Book review Christian Ethics for a Digital Society by dr. Kate Ott

Introduction

One of the reasons why I am pursuing my master’s in Theology is to connect theology and technology from an ethical perspective. This intersection is a new genre but more and more theologians are starting to write about this topic. The most recent book I read is the book Christian Ethics for a Digital Society by dr. Kate Ott.1 The review starts with setting the stage, in which I will describe the context of the book and the writer. In the subsequent section I will summarize the key points of the book, which will be followed by a review and suggestions for the reader.

Setting the stage

Technology is playing an ever more important role in our daily lives which cries out for a critical and ethical engagement. However, according to the author, dr. Kate Ott, the majority of people isn’t able to provide such a response and react either in “crippling fear” or in “worshipful awe.”2 In her book she tries to move beyond the ignorance of the many, and come up with a critical engagement towards digital technology based on a daily ethical practice. According to Ott, traditional ethics “grounded in absolutes or calculations” will not suffice but different ethical approaches are needed that “embrace growth, interdependence, and creativity.”3 In the book she advocates for Christians to develop a digital literacy, which does not only mean reflection about technology, but also applying this in such a way that this leads to a “more just and inclusive world.”4 The interesting thing about the book is that the author is not a technologist but has a background in feminist theories and sexual ethics.5 Ott, who currently teaches at Drew University in the United States, uses this background and methods to come up with a practical ethical framework based on “embodiment and interdependence with creation.”6 In a way she has documented her quest to a critical and ethical engagement with digital technology from an outsider’s perspective. I have been working in the world of (software) technology for last two decades and I have read her book from a technology insider’s perspective. I must admit that the author has done a great job in explaining what technology does and bringing this into conversation with theology and ethics. The result is a unique book that not only provides ‘food for thought’ but challenges the reader to look in the screen (not in the mirror) and make a change.

Key points of the book

The book is structured around four themes from the world of digital technology: algorithms, social interaction using digital technology, archiving and surveillance technology and the environmental impact digital technology has on our planet. Each chapter provides an introduction to the topic and a critical theological and ethical reflection, or as the reviewer Jen Jones puts it “Each chapter extends discernment of digital technology encompassing individual, relational, and societal considerations and implications.”7 In the concluding chapter Ethical Hacking and Hacking Ethics, Ott drives the key points of the previous chapters home in proposing to approach digital technology like an ethical hacker. Hacking normally has a negative connotation to it, but transforming the digital society requires the mindset of a hacker and entails “the ethical call to gain access to the ecosystem of digital technologies and define the vulnerabilities to be patched as the perpetuation of social inequalities and injustices.”8 I will briefly discuss the key points of each chapter (theme) below.

Algorithms

The first chapter about algorithms, called Programming for Difference, is a topic that is closely related to my professional life.9 Algorithms are one of the most important components of digital technology and they mediate how we interact with the world. Based on data, algorithms make predictions that e.g., inform our internet searches, movie recommendations and social media feeds. In a way, algorithms adapt towards our needs and they make our lives more individualized and seem to promote diversity.10 However, Ott is quite right when she exposes the algorithmic paradox of diversity, as algorithms reduce human beings to quantifiable units and impose an “imperial dominance of sameness.”11 People are much more homogeneous than they are willing to admit and algorithms reflect and amplify their cultural biases. Many people unconsciously accept what the algorithms feed them and in this way, they are unaware of how the values of these algorithms shape their lives.12 Ott uses the Tower of Babel narrative (Gen. 11:1-9) to analyze algorithms from a theological and ethical point of view. This story is one of the most frequently used stories in the Bible used by theologians and biblical scholars, when they want to put technology in a biblical context. The key message is that humans in our era use technology in order to become more like God themselves, and in this way they resemble the people who tried to build the tower of Babel. God punishes the people by bringing confusion among the people by letting them speak different languages. Ott has a different hermeneutical approach, which clearly reveals her roots in feminist theology, emphasizing that it was God’s intention to have multiple languages as this is a token of diversity which is “a defining feature of creation.”13 In her opinion it is not the building of the tower that God condemns, but it is the use of a single universal language that erases all differences.14  She quotes the American professor in journalism Jack Lule to underscore how digital services providers in our time can be compared to the Babel narrative:

Tech Giants on the other hand consider digital technology and electronic communication a way of regaining what was lost at Babel. They suggest both through translation and the ubiquity of common media that again one language is being created.15

The quote above is a good example of the algorithmic paradox Kate Ott brings forward in her book. Algorithms are the language of our time and shape our culture in such a way that many are unaware of. One of the best parts in the book that I wholeheartedly agree with, is that she calls for a digital literacy in order to respond to digital technology in an ethical manner or as she puts it: “everyday ethical living in a digital world requires curiosity and basic literacy with how digital technology functions.”16 An appropriate ethical response to algorithms starts with an awareness how they function and how they do not promote diversity by default. Ott’s call to action is to actively stand up and defy algorithmic bias as much as one proportionally can. Those with greater knowledge and influence on how algorithms function, think of programmers or data scientists, have a greater responsibility than those who are end users.17 By actively engaging and by deliberate interaction with algorithms we become more digitally fluent and are co-creators who are asked to actively promote diversity and prevent that we all speak the same language powered by algorithms.

Social interactions on digital platforms

In the second chapter, titled Networked Selves, Kate Ott zooms in on the role digital platforms play on relationships people have with themselves, others and God. A lot of interactions between humans has shifted from the physical world to the digital world and especially social networking platforms, often referred to as social media, play an important role in this. This networked understanding of the self is the key ingredient of this chapter and Ott focusses on the role data plays in forming our identity, Ott calls this the datafied self, and our relationships with the other and God.18  Just like in the previous chapter it starts with the awareness of the role digital platforms play in the formation of our own identity; digital technology is no longer something separate, but it is completely integrated in our “being in the world,” in other words, we are “datafied, embodied, and spiritual beings.”19 This construct poses all kinds of moral questions about who we are supposed to be in relationship to ourselves, the other and to God, and for this Ott introduces the theological notion of attunement to help us orient ourselves. Attunement based on a trinitarian understanding of God is a model for being an innovative Christian that supports a networked approach of relationships and promotes inclusivity.20 The ethical approach that follows from the notion of attunement latches on to the approach how to deal with algorithms, as it was set out in the previous chapter. It starts with the awareness of how digital technology is using data to instrumentalize our relationships, especially on social media platforms, and how the algorithms used are based on values of the digital world.21 The algorithms can make us feel very networked, you can e.g. 500+ friends on Facebook, but they do not promote deeper relationships. The core value of attunement is to understand how this works and what role this plays in our lives.22 The identity that the algorithms compose of us is based on the data they have collected and processed, and this influences who we meet and what we see.23  This can have moral implications which many are unaware of. Digital platforms, powered by their algorithms, can promote bias and make us blind for the otherness of the others. An appropriate theological and ethical response, based on the notion of trinitarian attunement, is that we “recognize, understand, and liberate ourselves and society from racism and other moral deformations of our digitally embodied spirits if we are to live into God’s example of difference in unity as the imago dei of a networked self.”24

Archiving and surveillance technology

The previous chapter focused mainly on the way digital technology shapes our personal lives and relationships. In the third chapter Moral functions beyond the Delete key the primary focus is on how the boundary between private and public information is being changed by digital technology which raises ethical questions about privacy and surveillance.25 Digital platforms are a huge archive of all the digital interactions we have done, so every search, click, like and swipe is being stored and being used by the algorithms of the digital platforms. It seems that these platforms remember everything and that we live in a world where “forgetting has become a luxury.”26 In this chapter Ott focuses on the concept of forgiveness in the context of digital platforms that never forget. She uses the theological notion of metanoia for this and this is described as “the process by which faith positively enables the human capacity to make change.”27  The culmination of the amount of data archived has social shaping consequences at two levels. On the one hand it influences individual people’s behavior which raises moral questions about privacy, and on the other hand, at a more aggregated level, it raises questions about social surveillance. Again, data and algorithms have more impact on shaping behavior than the majority of people is aware of. And especially because of the “indelible nature of digital data” this can have great consequences.28 As seen in the previous chapters, an ethical response to this starts with awareness and deliberate actions on both the personal and legislative level.29 Some scholars suggest that a good response would be to be able to delete the data, however Ott claims that she prefers accountability at personal and systemic level (metanoia) over erasure. This would lead to better and restored relationships with others and with God.30

Environmental impact

The last theme Kate Ott covers in her book is about the environmental impact digital technology has. This chapter, dubbed Creation Connectivity, addresses a much-overlooked aspect of digital technology, which is the impact it has on the environment and the natural resources that are consumed. Since many people perceive digital technology as a potential solution to help fight environmental damage, they often don’t associate this with the environmental damage it inflicts.31 Ott argues for an “ecologically friendly digital technology” which is based on a theological model of interdependence with creation.32 This all starts, again, with raising awareness of the ecological footprint digital technology is making and for this Ott suggests the notion of mattering which is described by the sociologist Jennifer Gabrys as “it is a way to make an intangible both materially visible and have relevance or value.”33 By making the intangible visible, it should provoke people to think and ultimately would lead to an ethical response. Ott concludes the chapter that “awareness about the digital environmental impact is an important aspect of digital literacies” and this is an important ingredient for a Christian moral responsibility for a more just and diverse world.34

Ethical hacking

In the last chapter of the book, Ethical Hacking and Hacking Ethics, the author wraps her call to action up in the notion of ethical hacking. Hacking to her is an “ethical call to gain access to the ecosystem of digital technologies and define the vulnerabilities to be patched as the perpetuation of social inequalities and injustices.”35 The ethical responses she proposed in the previous chapters are about diversity, attunement metanoia and responsible co-creation.36 All can be summed up as increasing digital literacy in order to make a change. Ott argues that using a theological mindset can help us find a hermeneutical vocabulary that will help us interpret digital technology, and help us become a better datafied, spiritual and embodied being.37

Review and suggestions for the reader

Books about technology treated in the context of theology is an upcoming genre and I have read a couple of them. This book is clearly different, because of the author’s focus on social ethics and her outsider’s perspective. Ott does a great job in describing the current technological landscape and has clearly become proficient in what is happening in the world of digital technology. I must admit that, especially in the first chapter, she hits the nail on the head in discerning in how digital technology is influencing and shaping our lives. I also absolutely agree with her that we need to increase our digital literacy in order to start using digital technology in an ethical, responsible way. In the book theological and ethical concepts are innovatively intertwined and will leave the reader with lots of ‘food for thought’. The book is especially interesting for practitioners who want to learn more about how they should engage with digital technology in their Christian environment. This book will be helpful for e.g. ministers, theologians and philosophers. The book is less suited as a practical how-to guide in how to navigate as a Christian in the world of digital technology since it is more of an academic work. I found the chapter about the impact that digital technology has on our environment an eye-opener and I think lots of work has to be done in that space.

When you read the book, it becomes clear the author has a background in social and feminist/ womanist ethics. Her focus is predominantly on the power and biases digital technology embodies and how this can oppress and marginalize minorities and lead to less fair and unjust world. In my opinion she focuses too much on the oppressive and negative aspects that digital technology brings to bear and has left out counterexamples on how digital technology can help in creating a better world. The real world of digital technology, in my opinion, is more nuanced than the picture Ott paints. There are also many examples available on how e.g. algorithms and social media have increased the opportunities for refugees and helped physicians in third world countries to provide better care.38 My recommendation to other readers would be to complement reading this book with a book that focuses more on the positive outcomes digital technology offers. By contrasting and comparing both books one gets a more nuanced and better understanding on how digital technology works and what impact it has on our personal lives and society. Based on this, a robust ethical response can be grasped. In sum, I would definitely recommend reading this book for any Christian theologian or minister who is interested in the ethical consequences and workings of digital technology. Ott does an outstanding job in exposing the power digital technology has on our society and how this can lead to an unjust society. However due to the lack of focusing on the upside of digital technology I would recommend reading additional literature to inform one’s ethical response to digital technology.

References

Ficatier, Antonin. “Book Review: Kate Ott, Christian Ethics for a Digital Society.” Studies in Christian Ethics 33, no. 1 (2020): 130–133. https://doi.org/10.1177/0953946819883780d.

Jones, Jen. “Book Review: Kate M. Ott, Christian Ethics for a Digital Society.” Journal of Moral Theology 9, no.1 (2020): 249–250.

Ott, Kate M. Christian Ethics for a Digital Society. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield, 2019.


Notes

.